Previously, we didn't track string literals as known memory locations at all, so they all just got marked as `UnknownMemoryLocation`, just like an aribtrary read from a random pointer. This led to some confusing def-use chains, where it would look like the contents of a string literal were being written to by the side effect of an earlier function call, which of course is impossible.
To fix this, I've made two changes. First, each string literal is now given a corresponding `IRVariable` (specifically `IRStringLiteral`), since a string literal behaves more or less as a read-only global variable. Second, the `IRVariable` for each string literal is now marked `isReadOnly()`, which the alias analysis uses to determine that an arbitrary write to aliased memory will not overwrite the contents of a string literal.
I originally planned to treat all string literals with the same value as being the same memory location, since this is the usual behavior of modern compilers. However, this made implementing `IRVariable.getAST()` tricky for string literals, so I left them unpooled.
Expressions like the `e` in `e;` or `e, e2`, whose result is immediately
discarded, should not get a synthetic `CopyValue`. This removes a lot of
redundancy from the IR.
To prevent these expressions from being confused with the expressions
from which they get their result, the predicate
`getInstructionConvertedResultExpression` now suppresses results for
expressions that don't produce their own result. This should fix the
mapping between expressions and IR data-flow nodes.
This adds IndirectMustWriteSideEffects for constructor qualifiers. The
introduced sanity failures result from constructor calls without qualifier
operands in the IR
The C++ IR currently has a very clunky way of specifying the type of an IR entity (`Instruction`, `Operand`, `IRVariable`, etc.). There are three separate predicates: `getType()`, `isGLValue()`, and `getSize()`. All three are necessary, rather than just having a `getType()` predicate, because some IR entities have types that are not represented via an existing `Type` object in the AST. Examples include the type for an lvalue returned from a `VariableAddress` instruction, the type for an array slice being zero-initialized in a variable initializer, and several others. It is very easy for QL code to just check the `getType()` predicate, while forgetting to use `isGLValue()` to determine if that type is the actual type of the entity (the prvalue case) or the type referred to by a glvalue entity. Furthermore, the C++ type system creates potentially many different `Type` objects for the same underlying type (e.g. typedefs, using declarations, `const`/`volatile` qualifiers, etc.), making it more difficult to tell when two entities have semantically equivalent types.
In addition, other languages for which we want to enable the IR have somewhat different type systems. The various language type systems differ in their structure, although they tend to share the basic building blocks necessary for the IR.
To address all of the above problems, I've introduced a new class hierarchy, rooted at the class `IRType`, that represents a bare-bones type system that is independent of source language (at least across C/C++/C#/Java). A type's identity is based on its kind (signed integer, unsigned integer, floating-point, Boolean, blob, etc.), size and in the case of blob types, a "tag" to differentiate between different classes and structs. No distinction is made between, say `signed int` and plain `int`, or between different language integer types that have the same signedness and size (e.g. `unsigned int` vs. `wchar_t` on Linux). `IRType` is intended for use by language-agnostic IR-based analyses, including range analysis, dataflow, SSA construction, and alias analysis. The set of available `IRType`s is determined by predicate provided by the language library implementation (e.g. `hasSignedIntegerType(int byteSize)`.
In addition to `IRType`, each language now defines a type alias named `LanguageType`, representing the type of an IR entity in more language-specific terms. The only predicate requried on `LanguageType` is `getIRType()`, which returns the single `IRType` object for the language-neutral representation of that `LanguageType`. All other predicates on and subclasses of `LanguageType` are language-specific. There may be many instances of `LanguageType` that map to a given `IRType`, to allow for typedefs, etc.
Most of the changes are mechanical changes in the IR construction code, to return the correct type for each IR entity. SSA construction has also been updated to avoid dependencies on language-specific types.
I have not yet removed the original `getType()` predicates that just return `Type`. These can be removed once we move the remaining existing libraries to use `IRType`.
Test results are, by design, pretty much unchanged. Once case changed for inline asm, because the previously IR generation for it played a little fast and loose with the input/output expressions. The test case now includes both input and output variables. The generated IR for `Conditional_LValue` is now more correct, because we now have a way to represent an lvalue of an lvalue. `syntax-zoo` is still a hot mess. Most of the changed outputs are due to wobble from having multiple functions with the same name, but with a slightly different order of evaluation due to the type changes. Others are wobble from already-invalid IR. A couple non-wobbly places have improved slightly, though.
The C# part of this change is waiting for #2005 to be merged, since that has some of the necessary C# implementation.
