Merge pull request #17363 from michaelnebel/modelgen/fieldbasedimprovements

C#/Java: Content based model generation improvements.

csharp/ql/lib/semmle/code/csharp/dataflow/internal/DataFlowPublic.qll

@@ -299,9 +299,12 @@ class ContentSet extends TContentSet {
    */
   predicate isProperty(Property p) { this = TPropertyContentSet(p) }
 
-  /** Holds if this content set represent the field `f`. */
+  /** Holds if this content set represents the field `f`. */
   predicate isField(Field f) { this.isSingleton(TFieldContent(f)) }
 
+  /** Holds if this content set represents the synthetic field `s`. */
+  predicate isSyntheticField(string s) { this.isSingleton(TSyntheticFieldContent(s)) }
+
   /** Holds if this content set represents an element in a collection. */
   predicate isElement() { this.isSingleton(TElementContent()) }
 

csharp/ql/src/utils/modelgenerator/CaptureContentSummaryModels.ql

@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
+/**
+ * @name Capture content based summary models.
+ * @description Finds applicable content based summary models to be used by other queries.
+ * @kind diagnostic
+ * @id cs/utils/modelgenerator/contentbased-summary-models
+ * @tags modelgenerator
+ */
+
+import internal.CaptureModels
+
+from DataFlowSummaryTargetApi api, string flow
+where flow = captureContentFlow(api)
+select flow order by flow

csharp/ql/src/utils/modelgenerator/internal/CaptureModels.qll

@@ -127,7 +127,7 @@ string captureQualifierFlow(DataFlowSummaryTargetApi api) {
     api = returnNodeEnclosingCallable(ret) and
     isOwnInstanceAccessNode(ret)
   ) and
-  result = Printing::asValueModel(api, qualifierString(), "ReturnValue")
+  result = Printing::asLiftedValueModel(api, qualifierString(), "ReturnValue")
 }
 
 private int accessPathLimit0() { result = 2 }
@@ -237,7 +237,7 @@ string captureThroughFlow0(
     input = parameterNodeAsInput(p) and
     output = getOutput(returnNodeExt) and
     input != output and
-    result = Printing::asTaintModel(api, input, output)
+    result = Printing::asLiftedTaintModel(api, input, output)
   )
 }
 
@@ -291,26 +291,257 @@ private string getContent(PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath ap, int i) {
   )
 }
 
+/**
+ * Gets the MaD string representation of a store step access path.
+ */
 private string printStoreAccessPath(PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath ap) {
   result = concat(int i | | getContent(ap, i), "" order by i)
 }
 
+/**
+ * Gets the MaD string representation of a read step access path.
+ */
 private string printReadAccessPath(PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath ap) {
   result = concat(int i | | getContent(ap, i), "" order by i desc)
 }
 
-string captureContentFlow(DataFlowSummaryTargetApi api) {
+/**
-  exists(
+ * Holds if the access path `ap` contains a field or synthetic field access.
-    DataFlow::ParameterNode p, ReturnNodeExt returnNodeExt, string input, string output,
+ */
-    PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath reads, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath stores,
+private predicate mentionsField(PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath ap) {
-    boolean preservesValue
+  exists(ContentSet head, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath tail |
+    head = ap.getHead() and
+    tail = ap.getTail()
   |
-    PropagateContentFlow::flow(p, reads, returnNodeExt, stores, preservesValue) and
+    mentionsField(tail) or isField(head)
-    returnNodeExt.getEnclosingCallable() = api and
+  )
+}
+
+private predicate apiFlow(
+  DataFlowSummaryTargetApi api, DataFlow::ParameterNode p, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath reads,
+  ReturnNodeExt returnNodeExt, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath stores, boolean preservesValue
+) {
+  PropagateContentFlow::flow(p, reads, returnNodeExt, stores, preservesValue) and
+  returnNodeExt.getEnclosingCallable() = api and
+  p.getEnclosingCallable() = api
+}
+
+/**
+ * A class of APIs relevant for modeling using content flow.
+ * The following heuristic is applied:
+ * Content flow is only relevant for an API, if
+ *    #content flow <= 2 * #parameters + 3
+ * If an API produces more content flow, it is likely that
+ * 1. Types are not sufficiently constrained leading to a combinatorial
+ * explosion in dispatch and thus in the generated summaries.
+ * 2. It is a reasonable approximation to use the non-content based flow
+ * detection instead, as reads and stores would use a significant
+ * part of an objects internal state.
+ */
+private class ContentDataFlowSummaryTargetApi extends DataFlowSummaryTargetApi {
+  ContentDataFlowSummaryTargetApi() {
+    count(string input, string output |
+      exists(
+        DataFlow::ParameterNode p, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath reads,
+        ReturnNodeExt returnNodeExt, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath stores
+      |
+        apiFlow(this, p, reads, returnNodeExt, stores, _) and
+        input = parameterNodeAsContentInput(p) + printReadAccessPath(reads) and
+        output = getContentOutput(returnNodeExt) + printStoreAccessPath(stores)
+      )
+    ) <= 2 * this.getNumberOfParameters() + 3
+  }
+}
+
+pragma[nomagic]
+private predicate apiContentFlow(
+  ContentDataFlowSummaryTargetApi api, DataFlow::ParameterNode p,
+  PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath reads, ReturnNodeExt returnNodeExt,
+  PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath stores, boolean preservesValue
+) {
+  PropagateContentFlow::flow(p, reads, returnNodeExt, stores, preservesValue) and
+  returnNodeExt.getEnclosingCallable() = api and
+  p.getEnclosingCallable() = api
+}
+
+/**
+ * Holds if any of the content sets in `path` translates into a synthetic field.
+ */
+private predicate hasSyntheticContent(PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath path) {
+  exists(PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath tail, ContentSet head |
+    head = path.getHead() and
+    tail = path.getTail()
+  |
+    exists(getSyntheticName(head)) or
+    hasSyntheticContent(tail)
+  )
+}
+
+/**
+ * A module containing predicates for validating access paths containing content sets
+ * that translates into synthetic fields, when used for generated summary models.
+ */
+private module AccessPathSyntheticValidation {
+  /**
+   * Holds if there exists an API that has content flow from `read` (on type `t1`)
+   * to `store` (on type `t2`).
+   */
+  private predicate step(
+    Type t1, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath read, Type t2, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath store
+  ) {
+    exists(DataFlow::ParameterNode p, ReturnNodeExt returnNodeExt |
+      p.getType() = t1 and
+      returnNodeExt.getType() = t2 and
+      apiContentFlow(_, p, read, returnNodeExt, store, _)
+    )
+  }
+
+  /**
+   * Holds if there exists an API that has content flow from `read` (on type `t1`)
+   * to `store` (on type `t2`), where `read` does not have synthetic content and `store` does.
+   *
+   * Step A -> Synth.
+   */
+  private predicate synthPathEntry(
+    Type t1, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath read, Type t2, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath store
+  ) {
+    not hasSyntheticContent(read) and
+    hasSyntheticContent(store) and
+    step(t1, read, t2, store)
+  }
+
+  /**
+   * Holds if there exists an API that has content flow from `read` (on type `t1`)
+   * to `store` (on type `t2`), where `read` has synthetic content
+   * and `store` does not.
+   *
+   * Step Synth -> A.
+   */
+  private predicate synthPathExit(
+    Type t1, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath read, Type t2, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath store
+  ) {
+    hasSyntheticContent(read) and
+    not hasSyntheticContent(store) and
+    step(t1, read, t2, store)
+  }
+
+  /**
+   * Holds if there exists a path of steps from `read` to an exit.
+   *
+   * read ->* Synth -> A
+   */
+  private predicate reachesSynthExit(Type t, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath read) {
+    synthPathExit(t, read, _, _)
+    or
+    hasSyntheticContent(read) and
+    exists(PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath mid, Type midType |
+      hasSyntheticContent(mid) and
+      step(t, read, midType, mid) and
+      reachesSynthExit(midType, mid.reverse())
+    )
+  }
+
+  /**
+   * Holds if there exists a path of steps from an entry to `store`.
+   *
+   * A -> Synth ->* store
+   */
+  private predicate synthEntryReaches(Type t, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath store) {
+    synthPathEntry(_, _, t, store)
+    or
+    hasSyntheticContent(store) and
+    exists(PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath mid, Type midType |
+      hasSyntheticContent(mid) and
+      step(midType, mid, t, store) and
+      synthEntryReaches(midType, mid.reverse())
+    )
+  }
+
+  /**
+   * Holds if at least one of the access paths `read` (on type `t1`) and `store` (on type `t2`)
+   * contain content that will be translated into a synthetic field, when being used in
+   * a MaD summary model, and if there is a range of APIs, such that
+   * when chaining their flow access paths, there exists access paths `A` and `B` where
+   * A ->* read -> store ->* B and where `A` and `B` do not contain content that will
+   * be translated into a synthetic field.
+   *
+   * This is needed because we don't want to include summaries that reads from or
+   * stores into a "dead" synthetic field.
+   *
+   * Example:
+   * Assume we have a type `t` (in this case `t1` = `t2`) with methods `getX` and
+   * `setX`, which gets and sets a private field `X` on `t`.
+   * This would lead to the following content flows
+   * getX : Argument[this].SyntheticField[t.X] -> ReturnValue.
+   * setX : Argument[0] -> Argument[this].SyntheticField[t.X]
+   * As the reads and stores are on synthetic fields we should only make summaries
+   * if both of these methods exist.
+   */
+  pragma[nomagic]
+  predicate acceptReadStore(
+    Type t1, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath read, Type t2, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath store
+  ) {
+    synthPathEntry(t1, read, t2, store) and reachesSynthExit(t2, store.reverse())
+    or
+    exists(PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath store0 | store0.reverse() = read |
+      synthEntryReaches(t1, store0) and synthPathExit(t1, read, t2, store)
+      or
+      synthEntryReaches(t1, store0) and
+      step(t1, read, t2, store) and
+      reachesSynthExit(t2, store.reverse())
+    )
+  }
+}
+
+/**
+ * Holds, if the API `api` has relevant flow from `read` on `p` to `store` on `returnNodeExt`.
+ * Flow is considered relevant,
+ * 1. If `read` or `store` do not contain a content set that translates into a synthetic field.
+ * 2. If `read` or `store` contain a content set that translates into a synthetic field, and if
+ * the synthetic content is "live" on the relevant declaring type.
+ */
+private predicate apiRelevantContentFlow(
+  ContentDataFlowSummaryTargetApi api, DataFlow::ParameterNode p,
+  PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath read, ReturnNodeExt returnNodeExt,
+  PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath store, boolean preservesValue
+) {
+  apiContentFlow(api, p, read, returnNodeExt, store, preservesValue) and
+  (
+    not hasSyntheticContent(read) and not hasSyntheticContent(store)
+    or
+    AccessPathSyntheticValidation::acceptReadStore(p.getType(), read, returnNodeExt.getType(), store)
+  )
+}
+
+pragma[nomagic]
+private predicate captureContentFlow0(
+  ContentDataFlowSummaryTargetApi api, string input, string output, boolean preservesValue,
+  boolean lift
+) {
+  exists(
+    DataFlow::ParameterNode p, ReturnNodeExt returnNodeExt, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath reads,
+    PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath stores
+  |
+    apiRelevantContentFlow(api, p, reads, returnNodeExt, stores, preservesValue) and
     input = parameterNodeAsContentInput(p) + printReadAccessPath(reads) and
     output = getContentOutput(returnNodeExt) + printStoreAccessPath(stores) and
     input != output and
-    result = Printing::asModel(api, input, output, preservesValue)
+    (if mentionsField(reads) or mentionsField(stores) then lift = false else lift = true)
+  )
+}
+
+/**
+ * Gets the content based summary model(s) of the API `api` (if there is flow from a parameter to
+ * the return value or a parameter).
+ *
+ * Models are lifted to the best type in case the read and store access paths do not
+ * contain a field or synthetic field access.
+ */
+string captureContentFlow(ContentDataFlowSummaryTargetApi api) {
+  exists(string input, string output, boolean lift, boolean preservesValue |
+    captureContentFlow0(api, input, output, _, lift) and
+    preservesValue = max(boolean p | captureContentFlow0(api, input, output, p, lift)) and
+    result = Printing::asModel(api, input, output, preservesValue, lift)
   )
 }
 

csharp/ql/src/utils/modelgenerator/internal/CaptureModelsSpecific.qll

@@ -390,23 +390,47 @@ private string getFullyQualifiedName(Declaration d) {
 }
 
 /**
- * Gets the MaD string representation of the contentset `c`.
+ * Holds if the content set `c` is a field, property or synthetic field.
+ */
+predicate isField(ContentSet c) { c.isField(_) or c.isSyntheticField(_) or c.isProperty(_) }
+
+/**
+ * Gets the MaD synthetic name string representation for the content set `c`, if any.
+ */
+string getSyntheticName(DataFlow::ContentSet c) {
+  exists(CS::Field f |
+    not f.isEffectivelyPublic() and
+    c.isField(f) and
+    result = getFullyQualifiedName(f)
+  )
+  or
+  exists(CS::Property p |
+    not p.isEffectivelyPublic() and
+    c.isProperty(p) and
+    result = getFullyQualifiedName(p)
+  )
+  or
+  c.isSyntheticField(result)
+}
+
+/**
+ * Gets the MaD string representation of the content set `c`.
  */
 string printContent(DataFlow::ContentSet c) {
   exists(CS::Field f, string name | name = getFullyQualifiedName(f) |
     c.isField(f) and
-    if f.isEffectivelyPublic()
+    f.isEffectivelyPublic() and
-    then result = "Field[" + name + "]"
+    result = "Field[" + name + "]"
-    else result = "SyntheticField[" + name + "]"
   )
   or
   exists(CS::Property p, string name | name = getFullyQualifiedName(p) |
     c.isProperty(p) and
-    if p.isEffectivelyPublic()
+    p.isEffectivelyPublic() and
-    then result = "Property[" + name + "]"
+    result = "Property[" + name + "]"
-    else result = "SyntheticField[" + name + "]"
   )
   or
+  result = "SyntheticField[" + getSyntheticName(c) + "]"
+  or
   c.isElement() and
   result = "Element"
 }

csharp/ql/src/utils/modelgenerator/internal/CaptureTypeBasedSummaryModels.qll

@@ -223,7 +223,7 @@ class TypeBasedFlowTargetApi extends Specific::SummaryTargetApi {
       output(this, tp, output) and
       input != output
     |
-      result = Printing::asValueModel(this, input, output)
+      result = Printing::asLiftedValueModel(this, input, output)
     )
   }
 }

csharp/ql/test/utils/modelgenerator/dataflow/Summaries.cs

@@ -66,7 +66,14 @@ public class BasicFlow
 
 public class CollectionFlow
 {
-    private string tainted;
+    private readonly string tainted;
+
+    // summary=Models;CollectionFlow;false;CollectionFlow;(System.String);;Argument[0];Argument[this];taint;df-generated
+    // contentbased-summary=Models;CollectionFlow;false;CollectionFlow;(System.String);;Argument[0];Argument[this].SyntheticField[Models.CollectionFlow.tainted];value;df-generated
+    public CollectionFlow(string s)
+    {
+        tainted = s;
+    }
 
     // summary=Models;CollectionFlow;false;ReturnArrayElement;(System.Object[]);;Argument[0].Element;ReturnValue;taint;df-generated
     // contentbased-summary=Models;CollectionFlow;false;ReturnArrayElement;(System.Object[]);;Argument[0].Element;ReturnValue;value;df-generated
@@ -177,7 +184,14 @@ public class CollectionFlow
 
 public class IEnumerableFlow
 {
-    private string tainted;
+    private readonly string tainted;
+
+    // summary=Models;IEnumerableFlow;false;IEnumerableFlow;(System.String);;Argument[0];Argument[this];taint;df-generated
+    // contentbased-summary=Models;IEnumerableFlow;false;IEnumerableFlow;(System.String);;Argument[0];Argument[this].SyntheticField[Models.IEnumerableFlow.tainted];value;df-generated
+    public IEnumerableFlow(string s)
+    {
+        tainted = s;
+    }
 
     // SPURIOUS-summary=Models;IEnumerableFlow;false;ReturnIEnumerable;(System.Collections.Generic.IEnumerable<System.String>);;Argument[0].Element;ReturnValue;taint;df-generated
     // contentbased-summary=Models;IEnumerableFlow;false;ReturnIEnumerable;(System.Collections.Generic.IEnumerable<System.String>);;Argument[0];ReturnValue;value;df-generated
@@ -611,10 +625,17 @@ public class Inheritance
 
     public class DImpl : D
     {
-        private string tainted;
+        private readonly string tainted;
+
+        // summary=Models;Inheritance+DImpl;false;DImpl;(System.String);;Argument[0];Argument[this];taint;df-generated
+        // contentbased-summary=Models;Inheritance+DImpl;false;DImpl;(System.String);;Argument[0];Argument[this].SyntheticField[Models.Inheritance+DImpl.tainted];value;df-generated
+        public DImpl(string s)
+        {
+            tainted = s;
+        }
 
         // summary=Models;Inheritance+IPublic3;true;get_Prop;();;Argument[this];ReturnValue;taint;df-generated
-        // contentbased-summary=Models;Inheritance+IPublic3;true;get_Prop;();;Argument[this].SyntheticField[Models.Inheritance+DImpl.tainted];ReturnValue;value;df-generated
+        // contentbased-summary=Models;Inheritance+DImpl;true;get_Prop;();;Argument[this].SyntheticField[Models.Inheritance+DImpl.tainted];ReturnValue;value;df-generated
         public override string Prop { get { return tainted; } }
     }
 }
@@ -680,3 +701,140 @@ public class NestedFieldFlow
         return new NestedFieldFlow() { FieldA = x };
     }
 }
+
+public class SyntheticFields
+{
+    private string value1;
+    private string value2;
+    private string value3;
+
+    private string chainBegin;
+    private string chainEnd;
+
+    private string brokenChainBegin;
+    private string brokenChainEnd;
+
+    // summary=Models;SyntheticFields;false;SyntheticFields;(System.String);;Argument[0];Argument[this];taint;df-generated
+    // contentbased-summary=Models;SyntheticFields;false;SyntheticFields;(System.String);;Argument[0];Argument[this].SyntheticField[Models.SyntheticFields.value1];value;df-generated
+    public SyntheticFields(string v1)
+    {
+        value1 = v1;
+    }
+
+    // summary=Models;SyntheticFields;false;GetValue1;();;Argument[this];ReturnValue;taint;df-generated
+    // contentbased-summary=Models;SyntheticFields;false;GetValue1;();;Argument[this].SyntheticField[Models.SyntheticFields.value1];ReturnValue;value;df-generated
+    public string GetValue1()
+    {
+        return value1;
+    }
+
+    // summary=Models;SyntheticFields;false;GetValue2;();;Argument[this];ReturnValue;taint;df-generated
+    // contentbased-summary=Models;SyntheticFields;false;GetValue2;();;Argument[this].SyntheticField[Models.SyntheticFields.value2];ReturnValue;value;df-generated
+    public string GetValue2()
+    {
+        return value2;
+    }
+
+    // summary=Models;SyntheticFields;false;SetValue2;(System.String);;Argument[0];Argument[this];taint;df-generated
+    // contentbased-summary=Models;SyntheticFields;false;SetValue2;(System.String);;Argument[0];Argument[this].SyntheticField[Models.SyntheticFields.value2];value;df-generated
+    public void SetValue2(string v2)
+    {
+        value2 = v2;
+    }
+
+    // summary=Models;SyntheticFields;false;SetValue3;(System.String);;Argument[0];Argument[this];taint;df-generated
+    // No content based summary as value3 is a dead synthetic field.
+    public void SetValue3(string v3)
+    {
+        value3 = v3;
+    }
+
+    // summary=Models;SyntheticFields;false;SetChainBegin;(System.String);;Argument[0];Argument[this];taint;df-generated
+    // contentbased-summary=Models;SyntheticFields;false;SetChainBegin;(System.String);;Argument[0];Argument[this].SyntheticField[Models.SyntheticFields.chainBegin];value;df-generated
+    public void SetChainBegin(string v)
+    {
+        chainBegin = v;
+    }
+
+    // neutral=Models;SyntheticFields;CopyChainValue;();summary;df-generated
+    // contentbased-summary=Models;SyntheticFields;false;CopyChainValue;();;Argument[this].SyntheticField[Models.SyntheticFields.chainBegin];Argument[this].SyntheticField[Models.SyntheticFields.chainEnd];value;df-generated
+    public void CopyChainValue()
+    {
+        chainEnd = chainBegin;
+    }
+
+    // summary=Models;SyntheticFields;false;GetChainEnd;();;Argument[this];ReturnValue;taint;df-generated
+    // contentbased-summary=Models;SyntheticFields;false;GetChainEnd;();;Argument[this].SyntheticField[Models.SyntheticFields.chainEnd];ReturnValue;value;df-generated
+    public string GetChainEnd()
+    {
+        return chainEnd;
+    }
+
+    // summary=Models;SyntheticFields;false;SetBrokenChainBegin;(System.String);;Argument[0];Argument[this];taint;df-generated
+    // No content based summary as brokenChainBegin is a dead synthetic field.
+    public void SetBrokenChainBegin(string v)
+    {
+        brokenChainBegin = v;
+    }
+
+    // summary=Models;SyntheticFields;false;GetBrokenChainEnd;();;Argument[this];ReturnValue;taint;df-generated
+    // No content based summary as brokenChainEnd is a dead synthetic field.
+    public string GetBrokenChainEnd()
+    {
+        return brokenChainEnd;
+    }
+
+    public class InnerSyntheticFields
+    {
+        private readonly string value;
+
+        // summary=Models;SyntheticFields+InnerSyntheticFields;false;InnerSyntheticFields;(System.String);;Argument[0];Argument[this];taint;df-generated
+        // contentbased-summary=Models;SyntheticFields+InnerSyntheticFields;false;InnerSyntheticFields;(System.String);;Argument[0];Argument[this].SyntheticField[Models.SyntheticFields+InnerSyntheticFields.value];value;df-generated
+        public InnerSyntheticFields(string v)
+        {
+            value = v;
+        }
+
+        // summary=Models;SyntheticFields+InnerSyntheticFields;false;GetValue;();;Argument[this];ReturnValue;taint;df-generated
+        // contentbased-summary=Models;SyntheticFields+InnerSyntheticFields;false;GetValue;();;Argument[this].SyntheticField[Models.SyntheticFields+InnerSyntheticFields.value];ReturnValue;value;df-generated
+        public string GetValue()
+        {
+            return value;
+        }
+    }
+
+    // summary=Models;SyntheticFields;false;MakeInner;(System.String);;Argument[0];ReturnValue;taint;df-generated
+    // contentbased-summary=Models;SyntheticFields;false;MakeInner;(System.String);;Argument[0];ReturnValue.SyntheticField[Models.SyntheticFields+InnerSyntheticFields.value];value;df-generated
+    public InnerSyntheticFields MakeInner(string v)
+    {
+        return new InnerSyntheticFields(v);
+    }
+}
+
+public class SyntheticProperties
+{
+    private string Prop1 { get; set; }
+
+    private string Prop2 { get; set; }
+
+    // summary=Models;SyntheticProperties;false;SyntheticProperties;(System.String);;Argument[0];Argument[this];taint;df-generated
+    // contentbased-summary=Models;SyntheticProperties;false;SyntheticProperties;(System.String);;Argument[0];Argument[this].SyntheticField[Models.SyntheticProperties.Prop1];value;df-generated
+    public SyntheticProperties(string v1)
+    {
+        Prop1 = v1;
+    }
+
+    // summary=Models;SyntheticProperties;false;GetProp1;();;Argument[this];ReturnValue;taint;df-generated
+    // contentbased-summary=Models;SyntheticProperties;false;GetProp1;();;Argument[this].SyntheticField[Models.SyntheticProperties.Prop1];ReturnValue;value;df-generated
+    public string GetProp1()
+    {
+        return Prop1;
+    }
+
+    // summary=Models;SyntheticProperties;false;SetProp2;(System.String);;Argument[0];Argument[this];taint;df-generated
+    // No content based summary as Prop2 is a dead synthetic field.
+    public void SetProp2(string v)
+    {
+        Prop2 = v;
+    }
+}

java/ql/src/utils/modelgenerator/internal/CaptureModels.qll

@@ -127,7 +127,7 @@ string captureQualifierFlow(DataFlowSummaryTargetApi api) {
     api = returnNodeEnclosingCallable(ret) and
     isOwnInstanceAccessNode(ret)
   ) and
-  result = Printing::asValueModel(api, qualifierString(), "ReturnValue")
+  result = Printing::asLiftedValueModel(api, qualifierString(), "ReturnValue")
 }
 
 private int accessPathLimit0() { result = 2 }
@@ -237,7 +237,7 @@ string captureThroughFlow0(
     input = parameterNodeAsInput(p) and
     output = getOutput(returnNodeExt) and
     input != output and
-    result = Printing::asTaintModel(api, input, output)
+    result = Printing::asLiftedTaintModel(api, input, output)
   )
 }
 
@@ -291,26 +291,257 @@ private string getContent(PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath ap, int i) {
   )
 }
 
+/**
+ * Gets the MaD string representation of a store step access path.
+ */
 private string printStoreAccessPath(PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath ap) {
   result = concat(int i | | getContent(ap, i), "" order by i)
 }
 
+/**
+ * Gets the MaD string representation of a read step access path.
+ */
 private string printReadAccessPath(PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath ap) {
   result = concat(int i | | getContent(ap, i), "" order by i desc)
 }
 
-string captureContentFlow(DataFlowSummaryTargetApi api) {
+/**
-  exists(
+ * Holds if the access path `ap` contains a field or synthetic field access.
-    DataFlow::ParameterNode p, ReturnNodeExt returnNodeExt, string input, string output,
+ */
-    PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath reads, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath stores,
+private predicate mentionsField(PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath ap) {
-    boolean preservesValue
+  exists(ContentSet head, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath tail |
+    head = ap.getHead() and
+    tail = ap.getTail()
   |
-    PropagateContentFlow::flow(p, reads, returnNodeExt, stores, preservesValue) and
+    mentionsField(tail) or isField(head)
-    returnNodeExt.getEnclosingCallable() = api and
+  )
+}
+
+private predicate apiFlow(
+  DataFlowSummaryTargetApi api, DataFlow::ParameterNode p, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath reads,
+  ReturnNodeExt returnNodeExt, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath stores, boolean preservesValue
+) {
+  PropagateContentFlow::flow(p, reads, returnNodeExt, stores, preservesValue) and
+  returnNodeExt.getEnclosingCallable() = api and
+  p.getEnclosingCallable() = api
+}
+
+/**
+ * A class of APIs relevant for modeling using content flow.
+ * The following heuristic is applied:
+ * Content flow is only relevant for an API, if
+ *    #content flow <= 2 * #parameters + 3
+ * If an API produces more content flow, it is likely that
+ * 1. Types are not sufficiently constrained leading to a combinatorial
+ * explosion in dispatch and thus in the generated summaries.
+ * 2. It is a reasonable approximation to use the non-content based flow
+ * detection instead, as reads and stores would use a significant
+ * part of an objects internal state.
+ */
+private class ContentDataFlowSummaryTargetApi extends DataFlowSummaryTargetApi {
+  ContentDataFlowSummaryTargetApi() {
+    count(string input, string output |
+      exists(
+        DataFlow::ParameterNode p, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath reads,
+        ReturnNodeExt returnNodeExt, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath stores
+      |
+        apiFlow(this, p, reads, returnNodeExt, stores, _) and
+        input = parameterNodeAsContentInput(p) + printReadAccessPath(reads) and
+        output = getContentOutput(returnNodeExt) + printStoreAccessPath(stores)
+      )
+    ) <= 2 * this.getNumberOfParameters() + 3
+  }
+}
+
+pragma[nomagic]
+private predicate apiContentFlow(
+  ContentDataFlowSummaryTargetApi api, DataFlow::ParameterNode p,
+  PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath reads, ReturnNodeExt returnNodeExt,
+  PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath stores, boolean preservesValue
+) {
+  PropagateContentFlow::flow(p, reads, returnNodeExt, stores, preservesValue) and
+  returnNodeExt.getEnclosingCallable() = api and
+  p.getEnclosingCallable() = api
+}
+
+/**
+ * Holds if any of the content sets in `path` translates into a synthetic field.
+ */
+private predicate hasSyntheticContent(PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath path) {
+  exists(PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath tail, ContentSet head |
+    head = path.getHead() and
+    tail = path.getTail()
+  |
+    exists(getSyntheticName(head)) or
+    hasSyntheticContent(tail)
+  )
+}
+
+/**
+ * A module containing predicates for validating access paths containing content sets
+ * that translates into synthetic fields, when used for generated summary models.
+ */
+private module AccessPathSyntheticValidation {
+  /**
+   * Holds if there exists an API that has content flow from `read` (on type `t1`)
+   * to `store` (on type `t2`).
+   */
+  private predicate step(
+    Type t1, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath read, Type t2, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath store
+  ) {
+    exists(DataFlow::ParameterNode p, ReturnNodeExt returnNodeExt |
+      p.getType() = t1 and
+      returnNodeExt.getType() = t2 and
+      apiContentFlow(_, p, read, returnNodeExt, store, _)
+    )
+  }
+
+  /**
+   * Holds if there exists an API that has content flow from `read` (on type `t1`)
+   * to `store` (on type `t2`), where `read` does not have synthetic content and `store` does.
+   *
+   * Step A -> Synth.
+   */
+  private predicate synthPathEntry(
+    Type t1, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath read, Type t2, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath store
+  ) {
+    not hasSyntheticContent(read) and
+    hasSyntheticContent(store) and
+    step(t1, read, t2, store)
+  }
+
+  /**
+   * Holds if there exists an API that has content flow from `read` (on type `t1`)
+   * to `store` (on type `t2`), where `read` has synthetic content
+   * and `store` does not.
+   *
+   * Step Synth -> A.
+   */
+  private predicate synthPathExit(
+    Type t1, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath read, Type t2, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath store
+  ) {
+    hasSyntheticContent(read) and
+    not hasSyntheticContent(store) and
+    step(t1, read, t2, store)
+  }
+
+  /**
+   * Holds if there exists a path of steps from `read` to an exit.
+   *
+   * read ->* Synth -> A
+   */
+  private predicate reachesSynthExit(Type t, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath read) {
+    synthPathExit(t, read, _, _)
+    or
+    hasSyntheticContent(read) and
+    exists(PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath mid, Type midType |
+      hasSyntheticContent(mid) and
+      step(t, read, midType, mid) and
+      reachesSynthExit(midType, mid.reverse())
+    )
+  }
+
+  /**
+   * Holds if there exists a path of steps from an entry to `store`.
+   *
+   * A -> Synth ->* store
+   */
+  private predicate synthEntryReaches(Type t, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath store) {
+    synthPathEntry(_, _, t, store)
+    or
+    hasSyntheticContent(store) and
+    exists(PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath mid, Type midType |
+      hasSyntheticContent(mid) and
+      step(midType, mid, t, store) and
+      synthEntryReaches(midType, mid.reverse())
+    )
+  }
+
+  /**
+   * Holds if at least one of the access paths `read` (on type `t1`) and `store` (on type `t2`)
+   * contain content that will be translated into a synthetic field, when being used in
+   * a MaD summary model, and if there is a range of APIs, such that
+   * when chaining their flow access paths, there exists access paths `A` and `B` where
+   * A ->* read -> store ->* B and where `A` and `B` do not contain content that will
+   * be translated into a synthetic field.
+   *
+   * This is needed because we don't want to include summaries that reads from or
+   * stores into a "dead" synthetic field.
+   *
+   * Example:
+   * Assume we have a type `t` (in this case `t1` = `t2`) with methods `getX` and
+   * `setX`, which gets and sets a private field `X` on `t`.
+   * This would lead to the following content flows
+   * getX : Argument[this].SyntheticField[t.X] -> ReturnValue.
+   * setX : Argument[0] -> Argument[this].SyntheticField[t.X]
+   * As the reads and stores are on synthetic fields we should only make summaries
+   * if both of these methods exist.
+   */
+  pragma[nomagic]
+  predicate acceptReadStore(
+    Type t1, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath read, Type t2, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath store
+  ) {
+    synthPathEntry(t1, read, t2, store) and reachesSynthExit(t2, store.reverse())
+    or
+    exists(PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath store0 | store0.reverse() = read |
+      synthEntryReaches(t1, store0) and synthPathExit(t1, read, t2, store)
+      or
+      synthEntryReaches(t1, store0) and
+      step(t1, read, t2, store) and
+      reachesSynthExit(t2, store.reverse())
+    )
+  }
+}
+
+/**
+ * Holds, if the API `api` has relevant flow from `read` on `p` to `store` on `returnNodeExt`.
+ * Flow is considered relevant,
+ * 1. If `read` or `store` do not contain a content set that translates into a synthetic field.
+ * 2. If `read` or `store` contain a content set that translates into a synthetic field, and if
+ * the synthetic content is "live" on the relevant declaring type.
+ */
+private predicate apiRelevantContentFlow(
+  ContentDataFlowSummaryTargetApi api, DataFlow::ParameterNode p,
+  PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath read, ReturnNodeExt returnNodeExt,
+  PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath store, boolean preservesValue
+) {
+  apiContentFlow(api, p, read, returnNodeExt, store, preservesValue) and
+  (
+    not hasSyntheticContent(read) and not hasSyntheticContent(store)
+    or
+    AccessPathSyntheticValidation::acceptReadStore(p.getType(), read, returnNodeExt.getType(), store)
+  )
+}
+
+pragma[nomagic]
+private predicate captureContentFlow0(
+  ContentDataFlowSummaryTargetApi api, string input, string output, boolean preservesValue,
+  boolean lift
+) {
+  exists(
+    DataFlow::ParameterNode p, ReturnNodeExt returnNodeExt, PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath reads,
+    PropagateContentFlow::AccessPath stores
+  |
+    apiRelevantContentFlow(api, p, reads, returnNodeExt, stores, preservesValue) and
     input = parameterNodeAsContentInput(p) + printReadAccessPath(reads) and
     output = getContentOutput(returnNodeExt) + printStoreAccessPath(stores) and
     input != output and
-    result = Printing::asModel(api, input, output, preservesValue)
+    (if mentionsField(reads) or mentionsField(stores) then lift = false else lift = true)
+  )
+}
+
+/**
+ * Gets the content based summary model(s) of the API `api` (if there is flow from a parameter to
+ * the return value or a parameter).
+ *
+ * Models are lifted to the best type in case the read and store access paths do not
+ * contain a field or synthetic field access.
+ */
+string captureContentFlow(ContentDataFlowSummaryTargetApi api) {
+  exists(string input, string output, boolean lift, boolean preservesValue |
+    captureContentFlow0(api, input, output, _, lift) and
+    preservesValue = max(boolean p | captureContentFlow0(api, input, output, p, lift)) and
+    result = Printing::asModel(api, input, output, preservesValue, lift)
   )
 }
 

java/ql/src/utils/modelgenerator/internal/CaptureModelsSpecific.qll

@@ -340,16 +340,35 @@ predicate isAdditionalContentFlowStep(DataFlow::Node node1, DataFlow::Node node2
 }
 
 /**
- * Gets the MaD string representation of the contentset `c`.
+ * Holds if the content set `c` is a field or a synthetic field.
  */
-string printContent(ContentSet c) {
+predicate isField(ContentSet c) {
-  exists(Field f, string name |
+  c instanceof DataFlowUtil::FieldContent or
-    f = c.(DataFlowUtil::FieldContent).getField() and name = f.getQualifiedName()
+  c instanceof DataFlowUtil::SyntheticFieldContent
-  |
+}
-    if f.isPublic() then result = "Field[" + name + "]" else result = "SyntheticField[" + name + "]"
+
+/**
+ * Gets the MaD synthetic name string representation for the content set `c`, if any.
+ */
+string getSyntheticName(DataFlow::ContentSet c) {
+  exists(Field f |
+    not f.isPublic() and
+    f = c.(DataFlowUtil::FieldContent).getField() and
+    result = f.getQualifiedName()
   )
   or
-  result = "SyntheticField[" + c.(DataFlowUtil::SyntheticFieldContent).getField() + "]"
+  result = c.(DataFlowUtil::SyntheticFieldContent).getField()
+}
+
+/**
+ * Gets the MaD string representation of the content set `c`.
+ */
+string printContent(ContentSet c) {
+  exists(Field f | f = c.(DataFlowUtil::FieldContent).getField() and f.isPublic() |
+    result = "Field[" + f.getQualifiedName() + "]"
+  )
+  or
+  result = "SyntheticField[" + getSyntheticName(c) + "]"
   or
   c instanceof DataFlowUtil::CollectionContent and result = "Element"
   or

java/ql/src/utils/modelgenerator/internal/CaptureTypeBasedSummaryModels.qll

@@ -329,7 +329,7 @@ class TypeBasedFlowTargetApi extends Specific::SummaryTargetApi {
       output(this, tv, output) and
       input != output
     |
-      result = Printing::asValueModel(this, input, output)
+      result = Printing::asLiftedValueModel(this, input, output)
     )
   }
 }

java/ql/test/utils/modelgenerator/dataflow/p/InnerHolder.java

@@ -37,8 +37,14 @@ public final class InnerHolder {
   }
 
   // summary=p;InnerHolder;false;getValue;();;Argument[this];ReturnValue;taint;df-generated
-  // contentbased-summary=p;InnerHolder;false;getValue;();;Argument[this].SyntheticField[p.InnerHolder.context].SyntheticField[p.InnerHolder$Context.value];ReturnValue;value;df-generated
+  // contentbased-summary=p;InnerHolder;false;getValue;();;Argument[this].SyntheticField[p.InnerHolder.sb];ReturnValue;taint;df-generated
   public String getValue() {
+    return sb.toString();
+  }
+
+  // summary=p;InnerHolder;false;getContextValue;();;Argument[this];ReturnValue;taint;df-generated
+  // contentbased-summary=p;InnerHolder;false;getContextValue;();;Argument[this].SyntheticField[p.InnerHolder.context].SyntheticField[p.InnerHolder$Context.value];ReturnValue;value;df-generated
+  public String getContextValue() {
     return context.getValue();
   }
 }

java/ql/test/utils/modelgenerator/dataflow/p/Joiner.java

@@ -22,8 +22,7 @@ public final class Joiner {
   // summary=p;Joiner;false;Joiner;(CharSequence,CharSequence,CharSequence);;Argument[1];Argument[this];taint;df-generated
   // summary=p;Joiner;false;Joiner;(CharSequence,CharSequence,CharSequence);;Argument[2];Argument[this];taint;df-generated
   // contentbased-summary=p;Joiner;false;Joiner;(CharSequence,CharSequence,CharSequence);;Argument[0];Argument[this].SyntheticField[p.Joiner.delimiter];taint;df-generated
-  // contentbased-summary=p;Joiner;false;Joiner;(CharSequence,CharSequence,CharSequence);;Argument[1];Argument[this].SyntheticField[p.Joiner.prefix];taint;df-generated
+  // No content based summaries for prefix and suffix as they are "dead" synthetic fields.
-  // contentbased-summary=p;Joiner;false;Joiner;(CharSequence,CharSequence,CharSequence);;Argument[2];Argument[this].SyntheticField[p.Joiner.suffix];taint;df-generated
   public Joiner(CharSequence delimiter, CharSequence prefix, CharSequence suffix) {
     Objects.requireNonNull(prefix, "The prefix must not be null");
     Objects.requireNonNull(delimiter, "The delimiter must not be null");
@@ -36,8 +35,7 @@ public final class Joiner {
 
   // summary=p;Joiner;false;setEmptyValue;(CharSequence);;Argument[0];Argument[this];taint;df-generated
   // summary=p;Joiner;false;setEmptyValue;(CharSequence);;Argument[this];ReturnValue;value;df-generated
-  // contentbased-summary=p;Joiner;false;setEmptyValue;(CharSequence);;Argument[0];Argument[this].SyntheticField[p.Joiner.emptyValue];taint;df-generated
+  // No content based summary as emptyValue is "dead" (synthetic)field.
-  // contentbased-summary=p;Joiner;false;setEmptyValue;(CharSequence);;Argument[0];ReturnValue.SyntheticField[p.Joiner.emptyValue];taint;df-generated
   // contentbased-summary=p;Joiner;false;setEmptyValue;(CharSequence);;Argument[this];ReturnValue;value;df-generated
   public Joiner setEmptyValue(CharSequence emptyValue) {
     this.emptyValue =
@@ -45,6 +43,12 @@ public final class Joiner {
     return this;
   }
 
+  // summary=p;Joiner;false;getDelimiter;();;Argument[this];ReturnValue;taint;df-generated
+  // contentbased-summary=p;Joiner;false;getDelimiter;();;Argument[this].SyntheticField[p.Joiner.delimiter];ReturnValue;value;df-generated
+  public String getDelimiter() {
+    return delimiter;
+  }
+
   private static int getChars(String s, char[] chars, int start) {
     int len = s.length();
     s.getChars(0, len, chars, start);
@@ -78,8 +82,8 @@ public final class Joiner {
   }
 
   // summary=p;Joiner;false;add;(CharSequence);;Argument[this];ReturnValue;value;df-generated
-  // contentbased-summary=p;Joiner;false;add;(CharSequence);;Argument[this].SyntheticField[p.Joiner.elts].ArrayElement;ReturnValue.SyntheticField[p.Joiner.elts].ArrayElement;value;df-generated
   // contentbased-summary=p;Joiner;false;add;(CharSequence);;Argument[this];ReturnValue;value;df-generated
+  // MISSING content based summaries for "elts". This could be a synthetic field.
   public Joiner add(CharSequence newElement) {
     final String elt = String.valueOf(newElement);
     if (elts == null) {
@@ -103,8 +107,8 @@ public final class Joiner {
   }
 
   // summary=p;Joiner;false;merge;(Joiner);;Argument[this];ReturnValue;value;df-generated
-  // contentbased-summary=p;Joiner;false;merge;(Joiner);;Argument[this].SyntheticField[p.Joiner.elts].ArrayElement;ReturnValue.SyntheticField[p.Joiner.elts].ArrayElement;value;df-generated
   // contentbased-summary=p;Joiner;false;merge;(Joiner);;Argument[this];ReturnValue;value;df-generated
+  // MISSING content based summaries for "elts". This could be a synthetic field.
   public Joiner merge(Joiner other) {
     Objects.requireNonNull(other);
     if (other.elts == null) {

java/ql/test/utils/modelgenerator/dataflow/p/MultiPaths.java

@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
+package p;
+
+public class MultiPaths {
+
+  // summary=p;MultiPaths;true;cond;(String,String);;Argument[0];ReturnValue;taint;df-generated
+  // contentbased-summary=p;MultiPaths;true;cond;(String,String);;Argument[0];ReturnValue;value;df-generated
+  public String cond(String x, String other) {
+    if (x == other) {
+      return x.substring(0, 100);
+    }
+    return x;
+  }
+}

java/ql/test/utils/modelgenerator/dataflow/p/MultipleImpls.java

@@ -30,18 +30,16 @@ public class MultipleImpls {
     private String foo;
 
     // summary=p;MultipleImpls$Strategy;true;doSomething;(String);;Argument[0];Argument[this];taint;df-generated
-    // A field based model should not be lifted if the field pertains to the concrete
+    // The content based summary is not lifted as it pertains to a (synthetic)field.
-    // implementation.
+    // contentbased-summary=p;MultipleImpls$Strat2;true;doSomething;(String);;Argument[0];Argument[this].SyntheticField[p.MultipleImpls$Strat2.foo];value;df-generated
-    // SPURIOUS-contentbased-summary=p;MultipleImpls$Strategy;true;doSomething;(String);;Argument[0];Argument[this].SyntheticField[p.MultipleImpls$Strat2.foo];value;df-generated
     public String doSomething(String value) {
       this.foo = value;
       return "none";
     }
 
     // summary=p;MultipleImpls$Strat2;true;getValue;();;Argument[this];ReturnValue;taint;df-generated
-    // A field based model should not be lifted if the field pertains to the concrete
+    // The content based summary is not lifted as it pertains to a (synthetic)field.
-    // implementation.
+    // contentbased-summary=p;MultipleImpls$Strat2;true;getValue;();;Argument[this].SyntheticField[p.MultipleImpls$Strat2.foo];ReturnValue;value;df-generated
-    // SPURIOUS-contentbased-summary=p;MultipleImpls$Strat2;true;getValue;();;Argument[this].SyntheticField[p.MultipleImpls$Strat2.foo];ReturnValue;value;df-generated
     public String getValue() {
       return this.foo;
     }

java/ql/test/utils/modelgenerator/dataflow/p/Pojo.java

@@ -26,9 +26,20 @@ public final class Pojo {
 
   public byte[] byteArray = new byte[] {1, 2, 3};
   private float[] floatArray = new float[] {1, 2, 3};
-  private char[] charArray = new char[] {'a', 'b', 'c'};
   private List<Character> charList = Arrays.asList('a', 'b', 'c');
-  private Byte[] byteObjectArray = new Byte[] {1, 2, 3};
+  private char[] charArray;
+  private Byte[] byteObjectArray;
+  private String stringValue1;
+  private String stringValue2;
+
+  // summary=p;Pojo;false;Pojo;(Byte[],char[]);;Argument[0];Argument[this];taint;df-generated
+  // summary=p;Pojo;false;Pojo;(Byte[],char[]);;Argument[1];Argument[this];taint;df-generated
+  // contentbased-summary=p;Pojo;false;Pojo;(Byte[],char[]);;Argument[0];Argument[this].SyntheticField[p.Pojo.byteObjectArray];value;df-generated
+  // contentbased-summary=p;Pojo;false;Pojo;(Byte[],char[]);;Argument[1];Argument[this].SyntheticField[p.Pojo.charArray];value;df-generated
+  public Pojo(Byte[] byteObjectArray, char[] charArray) {
+    this.byteObjectArray = byteObjectArray;
+    this.charArray = charArray;
+  }
 
   // summary=p;Pojo;false;getValue;();;Argument[this];ReturnValue;taint;df-generated
   // contentbased-summary=p;Pojo;false;getValue;();;Argument[this].SyntheticField[p.Pojo.value];ReturnValue;value;df-generated
@@ -75,6 +86,12 @@ public final class Pojo {
     return byteArray;
   }
 
+  // summary=p;Pojo;false;setByteArray;(byte[]);;Argument[0];Argument[this];taint;df-generated
+  // contentbased-summary=p;Pojo;false;setByteArray;(byte[]);;Argument[0];Argument[this].Field[p.Pojo.byteArray];value;df-generated
+  public void setByteArray(byte[] value) {
+    byteArray = value;
+  }
+
   // neutral=p;Pojo;getFloatArray;();summary;df-generated
   public float[] getFloatArray() {
     return floatArray;
@@ -91,7 +108,7 @@ public final class Pojo {
   }
 
   // summary=p;Pojo;false;getBoxedChars;();;Argument[this];ReturnValue;taint;df-generated
-  // contentbased-summary=p;Pojo;false;getBoxedChars;();;Argument[this].SyntheticField[p.Pojo.charList];ReturnValue;value;df-generated
+  // No content based summary as charList is a "dead" (synthetic)field.
   public List<Character> getBoxedChars() {
     return charList;
   }
@@ -117,4 +134,44 @@ public final class Pojo {
   public void fillIn(List<String> target) {
     target.add(value);
   }
+
+  // summary=p;Pojo;false;setStringValue1;(String);;Argument[0];Argument[this];taint;df-generated
+  // contentbased-summary=p;Pojo;false;setStringValue1;(String);;Argument[0];Argument[this].SyntheticField[p.Pojo.stringValue1];value;df-generated
+  public void setStringValue1(String value) {
+    this.stringValue1 = value;
+  }
+
+  // neutral=p;Pojo;copyStringValue;();summary;df-generated
+  // contentbased-summary=p;Pojo;false;copyStringValue;();;Argument[this].SyntheticField[p.Pojo.stringValue1];Argument[this].SyntheticField[p.Pojo.stringValue2];value;df-generated
+  public void copyStringValue() {
+    this.stringValue2 = this.stringValue1;
+  }
+
+  // summary=p;Pojo;false;getStringValue2;();;Argument[this];ReturnValue;taint;df-generated
+  // contentbased-summary=p;Pojo;false;getStringValue2;();;Argument[this].SyntheticField[p.Pojo.stringValue2];ReturnValue;value;df-generated
+  public String getStringValue2() {
+    return this.stringValue2;
+  }
+
+  public class InnerPojo {
+    private String value;
+
+    // summary=p;Pojo$InnerPojo;true;InnerPojo;(String);;Argument[0];Argument[this];taint;df-generated
+    // contentbased-summary=p;Pojo$InnerPojo;true;InnerPojo;(String);;Argument[0];Argument[this].SyntheticField[p.Pojo$InnerPojo.value];value;df-generated
+    public InnerPojo(String value) {
+      this.value = value;
+    }
+
+    // summary=p;Pojo$InnerPojo;true;getValue;();;Argument[this];ReturnValue;taint;df-generated
+    // contentbased-summary=p;Pojo$InnerPojo;true;getValue;();;Argument[this].SyntheticField[p.Pojo$InnerPojo.value];ReturnValue;value;df-generated
+    public String getValue() {
+      return value;
+    }
+  }
+
+  // summary=p;Pojo;false;makeInnerPojo;(String);;Argument[0];ReturnValue;taint;df-generated
+  // contentbased-summary=p;Pojo;false;makeInnerPojo;(String);;Argument[0];ReturnValue.SyntheticField[p.Pojo$InnerPojo.value];value;df-generated
+  public InnerPojo makeInnerPojo(String value) {
+    return new InnerPojo(value);
+  }
 }

java/ql/test/utils/modelgenerator/dataflow/p/PrivateFlowViaPublicInterface.java

@@ -29,9 +29,9 @@ public class PrivateFlowViaPublicInterface {
     }
 
     // summary=p;PrivateFlowViaPublicInterface$SPI;true;openStream;();;Argument[this];ReturnValue;taint;df-generated
-    // A field based model should not be lifted if the field pertains to the concrete
+    // This summary shouldn't be created because the method is private.
-    // implementation.
+    // This is most likely because the lifting logic hasn't been properly adapted.
-    // SPURIOUS-contentbased-summary=p;PrivateFlowViaPublicInterface$SPI;true;openStream;();;Argument[this].SyntheticField[p.PrivateFlowViaPublicInterface$PrivateImplWithSink.file];ReturnValue;taint;df-generated
+    // SPURIOUS-contentbased-summary=p;PrivateFlowViaPublicInterface$PrivateImplWithSink;false;openStream;();;Argument[this].SyntheticField[p.PrivateFlowViaPublicInterface$PrivateImplWithSink.file];ReturnValue;taint;df-generated
     @Override
     public OutputStream openStream() throws IOException {
       return new FileOutputStream(file);
@@ -54,9 +54,7 @@ public class PrivateFlowViaPublicInterface {
   }
 
   // summary=p;PrivateFlowViaPublicInterface;true;createAnSPI;(File);;Argument[0];ReturnValue;taint;df-generated
-  // A field based model should not be lifted if the field pertains to the concrete
+  // contentbased-summary=p;PrivateFlowViaPublicInterface;true;createAnSPI;(File);;Argument[0];ReturnValue.SyntheticField[p.PrivateFlowViaPublicInterface$PrivateImplWithSink.file];value;df-generated
-  // implementation.
-  // SPURIOUS-contentbased-summary=p;PrivateFlowViaPublicInterface;true;createAnSPI;(File);;Argument[0];ReturnValue.SyntheticField[p.PrivateFlowViaPublicInterface$PrivateImplWithSink.file];value;df-generated
   public static SPI createAnSPI(File file) {
     return new PrivateImplWithSink(file);
   }

shared/dataflow/codeql/dataflow/internal/ContentDataFlowImpl.qll

@@ -271,6 +271,38 @@ module MakeImplContentDataFlow<LocationSig Location, InputSig<Location> Lang> {
           result = head + "." + tail
         )
       }
+
+      private ContentSet getAtIndex(int i) {
+        i = 0 and
+        result = this.getHead()
+        or
+        i > 0 and
+        result = this.getTail().getAtIndex(i - 1)
+      }
+
+      private AccessPath reverse0(int i) {
+        i = -1 and result = TAccessPathNil()
+        or
+        i >= 0 and
+        result = TAccessPathCons(this.getAtIndex(i), this.reverse0(i - 1))
+      }
+
+      /**
+       * Gets the length of this access path.
+       */
+      private int length() {
+        result = 0 and this = TAccessPathNil()
+        or
+        result = 1 + this.getTail().length()
+      }
+
+      /**
+       * Gets the reversed access path, if any.
+       *
+       * Note that not all access paths have a reverse as these are not
+       * included by default in the IPA type.
+       */
+      AccessPath reverse() { result = this.reverse0(this.length() - 1) }
     }
 
     /**

shared/mad/codeql/mad/modelgenerator/ModelPrinting.qll

@@ -64,14 +64,23 @@ module ModelPrintingImpl<ModelPrintingLangSig Lang> {
 
     /**
      * Gets the summary model for `api` with `input`, `output` and `kind`.
+     * The model is lifted in case `lift` is true.
      */
     bindingset[input, output, kind]
-    private string asSummaryModel(Printing::SummaryApi api, string input, string output, string kind) {
+    private string asSummaryModel(
-      result =
+      Printing::SummaryApi api, string input, string output, string kind, boolean lift
-        asPartialModel(api.lift()) + input + ";" //
+    ) {
-          + output + ";" //
+      exists(Lang::Callable c |
-          + kind + ";" //
+        lift = true and c = api.lift()
-          + Printing::getProvenance()
+        or
+        lift = false and c = api
+      |
+        result =
+          asPartialModel(c) + input + ";" //
+            + output + ";" //
+            + kind + ";" //
+            + Printing::getProvenance()
+      )
     }
 
     string asNeutralSummaryModel(Printing::SummaryApi api) {
@@ -82,31 +91,35 @@ module ModelPrintingImpl<ModelPrintingLangSig Lang> {
     }
 
     /**
-     * Gets the value summary model for `api` with `input` and `output`.
+     * Gets the lifted value summary model for `api` with `input` and `output`.
      */
     bindingset[input, output]
-    string asValueModel(Printing::SummaryApi api, string input, string output) {
+    string asLiftedValueModel(Printing::SummaryApi api, string input, string output) {
-      result = asSummaryModel(api, input, output, "value")
+      result = asModel(api, input, output, true, true)
     }
 
     /**
-     * Gets the taint summary model for `api` with `input` and `output`.
+     * Gets the lifted taint summary model for `api` with `input` and `output`.
      */
     bindingset[input, output]
-    string asTaintModel(Printing::SummaryApi api, string input, string output) {
+    string asLiftedTaintModel(Printing::SummaryApi api, string input, string output) {
-      result = asSummaryModel(api, input, output, "taint")
+      result = asModel(api, input, output, false, true)
     }
 
     /**
      * Gets the summary model for `api` with `input` and `output`.
+     * (1) If `preservesValue` is true a "value" model is created.
+     * (2) If `lift` is true the model is lifted to the best possible type.
      */
     bindingset[input, output, preservesValue]
-    string asModel(Printing::SummaryApi api, string input, string output, boolean preservesValue) {
+    string asModel(
+      Printing::SummaryApi api, string input, string output, boolean preservesValue, boolean lift
+    ) {
       preservesValue = true and
-      result = asValueModel(api, input, output)
+      result = asSummaryModel(api, input, output, "value", lift)
       or
       preservesValue = false and
-      result = asTaintModel(api, input, output)
+      result = asSummaryModel(api, input, output, "taint", lift)
     }
 
     /**